Selling silver dollars in Cincinnati
Morgan dollars, Peace dollars and the odd trade dollar. We sort by date and mint mark and price the better coins one at a time.
Silver dollars around Cincinnati
Silver dollars were a common gift in Cincinnati families: one for a baptism, one for a first communion, one for a graduation. Many households ended up with a small stack in a dresser drawer, and some with a canvas bag from the bank.
We count every dollar, sort them by date and mint mark and grade the ones that might carry a premium. The written offer lists the better coins on their own lines.
Morgan dollars worth a closer look
Morgans were struck at Philadelphia, New Orleans, San Francisco, Carson City and, in 1921, Denver. Most common dates in worn condition sell close to silver. A short list of dates and conditions deserves extra attention.
- Any CC mint mark
- 1889-CC, 1893-S and 1895
- 1884-S and 1892-S in higher grades
- Early San Francisco dates with deep mirror fields
- Coins with natural rainbow toning
Peace dollars
Peace dollars were struck from 1921 to 1935, with a gap from 1929 to 1933. The 1921 high relief coin carries a premium in nearly any grade. The 1928 Philadelphia coin and the 1934-S are scarce. Most other dates sell for a modest premium over silver in circulated condition.
Grading silver dollars
Silver dollars are big coins and show wear and bag marks clearly. We look at the high points of the design, the fields and the luster. Bag marks from shipping are normal and part of the grade. Cleaning is not, and cleaned dollars sell for less, so please leave them as they are.
How the offer is laid out
We list the better dollars one per line, each with its date, mint mark, grade and price. Common circulated dollars are grouped together and priced as a group. You can see exactly where the premiums are and sell some dollars while keeping others.
Dollars kept as gifts
Silver dollars given at baptisms and graduations were often tucked into small envelopes or plastic holders with a date written on them. Leave them that way. The note does not change the price, but it helps the family remember which coin came from whom if they want to keep a few.
Certified silver dollars
Dollars in PCGS and NGC holders are priced on their certified grade and current demand. High-grade certified Morgans can sell for many times the price of a raw coin. We check each holder, look up the certification number and price it on the market for that exact grade.
Dollars we buy
- Morgan dollars, 1878 to 1904 and 1921
- Peace dollars, 1921 to 1935
- Trade dollars from the 1870s
- Seated Liberty dollars
- 40 percent silver Eisenhower dollars
- American Silver Eagles
- Graded and certified dollars
How silver dollars are priced
Morgan and Peace dollars are 90 percent silver and hold about 0.77 troy ounces each. A common worn dollar sells for a little more than its silver.
A smaller group of dates and mints sells for far more. Carson City dollars, early New Orleans and San Francisco dates in high grades and the 1921 high relief Peace dollar all carry strong premiums.
Further reading: How coin buyers figure an offer
Common questions
- Are Carson City dollars worth more?
- Usually, yes. Carson City coins are popular with collectors, and a few CC dates are hard to find.
- Are Eisenhower dollars silver?
- Most are not. Some proof and uncirculated versions struck at San Francisco from 1971 to 1976 are 40 percent silver.
- Do you buy bags of dollars?
- Yes. Bring the bag as it is, and we will count and sort the dollars together.