Coin and gold buyers in the Queen City
Sell your coins, gold and silver in Cincinnati
Bring the coffee can, the coin folders or the whole estate. We go through it piece by piece and hand you a written offer before you decide anything.
- Free appraisalNo charge to say no
- Paid the same dayCash or bank wire
- Both sides of the riverGreater Cincinnati and Northern Kentucky
What we buy most often
Bring it in a coffee can, a coin folder or a safe deposit box. Every piece gets its own line on the written offer.
-
Gold coinsDouble eagles, half eagles, Gold Eagles, Krugerrands and other gold coins.Get an offer -
Old coinsWheat cents, Buffalo nickels, Mercury dimes, old halves and whole jars of change.Get an offer
- Free appraisal, no charge to say no
- Every coin graded and every gram weighed in front of you
- Paid the same day by cash or bank wire
Cincinnati is a city of long-held houses. Families stay in Westwood, Price Hill, Mount Washington and Fort Thomas for forty years, and the coins pile up: a jar of wheat cents, a drawer of silver halves, a few gold pieces a grandparent bought and never mentioned. When it is finally time to sort it out, most people have no idea what any of it is worth.
That is the part we handle. We sort the silver from the copper, grade the coins that might carry a premium, weigh the gold and write down what we would pay for each piece. You can take the list home, compare it or sell on the spot.
Spot price per troy ounce
- Gold
- $3,737.98
- +0.34%
- Silver
- $45.53
- +1.04%
How selling works
Three steps, and you can stop after any of them.
Call or send the form
Tell us roughly what you have. We call back the same day and set a private time.
See everything checked
Coins are graded under magnification. Gold and silver go on a scale you can read.
Decide with the paper in hand
Sell and get paid that day, or keep it all along with the written list.
Coins with a Cincinnati past
By the middle of the 1800s Cincinnati was one of the largest cities in the country, built on river trade, pork packing and a huge wave of German immigrants who settled Over-the-Rhine. Those families kept savings in coin, and many sent money back and forth to relatives in Europe.
That history shows up in the collections we see today. Old German marks and silver coins sit next to Morgan dollars and Mercury dimes. Notes from Cincinnati national banks turn up in family Bibles. Gold coins come out of basement safes in Clifton and Hyde Park. We know what to look for in all of it.
- 1871 to 1945
German marks and silver
Imperial and Weimar silver coins carry metal value. Some states and dates bring far more.
- 1909 to 1958
Wheat cents
Most are worth a few cents. A handful of dates and mint marks are worth a lot more.
- Every offer
How we set a price
Metal content, grade and current demand, written down line by line.
Both sides of the river
We work with sellers across Hamilton County, the Mill Creek valley suburbs and the river towns of Northern Kentucky.
Common questions
Short answers to what Cincinnati sellers ask before they call.
Where can I sell old coins in Cincinnati?
Cincinnati Coin Buyers buys old coins, gold, silver and bullion by private appointment, Monday to Saturday. Call 513-270-5842 or send the form, and we will set a time to look at everything with you.
How do you decide what to pay?
Gold and silver are priced on their weight, purity and the live spot price. Collector coins are priced on grade and current demand. Every number is written on the offer.
Do you buy from Northern Kentucky?
Yes. We work with sellers in Covington, Newport, Fort Thomas and the rest of Northern Kentucky.
Is there a charge for the appraisal?
No. The appraisal is free, and you keep everything if you decide not to sell.
How do I get paid?
Smaller sales are paid in cash at the appointment. Larger sales can be paid by bank wire the same day.
From our coin notes
-
How coin buyers figure an offer
Metal content, grade and demand: what goes into a coin buyer's number.
-
Old German coins and marks: what they are worth
Imperial, Weimar and later German coins: which hold silver and which carry premiums.
-
What is a wheat penny worth?
Most wheat cents are common. Here are the dates worth checking.
Selling coins or gold around Cincinnati?
Book a free appraisal anywhere in Greater Cincinnati or Northern Kentucky. Every piece is checked in front of you and the offer is written down.